REPORT BY WILDFISH

The reality gap: An examination of Scottish farmed salmon

Summary:

This report first gives an overview of the various marketing tools used by the Scottish salmon farming industry to represent farmed salmon as a sustainable, healthy and eco-friendly protein choice. It then examines the environmental and welfare performance of Scotland’s seven salmon farming companies, all widely used in the hospitality and retail sectors.

Through analysis of publicly available data and company information, the report explores the contrast between the marketing used by the Scottish salmon industry to promote its products, and the reality of the industry’s huge negative environmental and welfare impacts.

The report finds that, despite assurances from certification schemes and celebrity endorsements, none of the seven salmon farming companies in Scotland has shown the ability to operate in such a way that protects
wild fish, the environment – both immediate and global – and farmed fish welfare. Across the world, open-net salmon farming is in a perilous state, with increased scrutiny on its high mortality rates and environmental costs.

The Scottish salmon farming industry is no different, with record mortalities (an estimated 17.4 million farmed salmon died on Scottish farms in 2023); a continued reliance on chemicals; and an inability to contain outbreaks of diseases and sea lice parasites, contributing to a reality that is far removed from the industry marketing.

To feed the world, recognize the interconnectedness of aquaculture and fisheries

Efforts to scale up aquaculture are increasingly framed as essential to global food security and ocean sustainability, yet such narratives often obscure the complex and interdependent relationships between aquaculture and wild-capture fisheries. This paper critically interrogates the dominant “feed the world” framing of aquaculture expansion, arguing that treating aquaculture and fisheries as isolated systems undermines social equity, ecological sustainability, and effective food policy.

Read More

Food fraud in the fisheries and aquaculture sector

The report reviews regulatory frameworks as well as standards such as those set by Codex Alimentarius, FAO guidelines, and GFSI‑benchmarked schemes, advocating for harmonized labelling, mandatory scientific names, and improved traceability. It emphasizes the role of consumer awareness and industry transparency in combating fraud.

Read More